Robert Sinton

     
     Robert Sinton was born on 6 Dec 1852 in Galashiels, SEL, SCT, which date comes from the date in Ernie's mother's birthday book, written in Robert's own hand, and matches the date in the Parish registers, also matches his age at marriage.^3,1,4 He was baptized on 13 Mar 1853 in SEL, SCT; the entry reading: Robert Sinton residenter at Raelees and his spouse had a child baptised by Rev John Campbell on the 13th March 1853 named Robert. Date of birth 6th December 1852. (this does not gel with his appearance in the 1851 census, although the absence of Rachel from the census could mean an enumerator's error).⁵
     Robert Sinton married Agnes Alexander, daughter of male Alexander, on 15 Sep 1879 in Tuam St, Christchurch, CBY, NZ, the intentions to marry show Robert as a labourer, resident Chch for 1 week, usually resident Ashburton, and aged 26, Agnes as 22, resid. Chch for 4 days, a servant, married by the Rev C Fraser in his Tuam St house.^6,7,8
     Robert Sinton died in Feb 1943 at Manutuke, Gisborne, ECP, NZ, at age 90; Christine's tree has Feb 1943 written above a crossed out 4 Sep. From Ernie³: "even my father William did not appear to know the names of his grandparents, because on his father Robert's death cert. the parents' names were left blank. He died Feb 1943 in Gisborne".^7,4,3
     
     The census of 30 Mar 1851 showed Joseph, James and Robert in the household of their parents Robert and Jane Park at Ralees, SEL, SCT, enumerated as Robert SINTON, 35, ag lab b Bowden, ROX, wife Jean, 35, b Roxburgh, ROX. Children: Mary, 11, scholar, b Bowden, ROX; Margaret, 9; James 7; Robert 4; Joseph 2, Janet 8m, all b Selkirk, SEL. Mother-in-law Mary REDPATH, married, 75, b Greenlaw, BEW (Note that in 1851 son Robert wasn't even a twinkle in his mother's eye, not being born until Dec 1852, but the film clearly shows the entry of a male, son named Robert aged 4 - but dtr Rachel, who should have been 4, female and at home, isn't listed).⁹ Robert Sinton appeared on the census of 1861 in a Private Hse, Raelees, SEL, SCT, in the household of Robert Sinton and Jane Sinton as son of Robert.^10,11
     The census of 1871 showed Joseph, Robert, Peter, John and William in the household of their parents Robert and Jane Park at Hartwoodburn, Par. of Selkirk, SEL, SCT, enumerated as SINTON: Robt, 55 ag lab b Bowden, ROX; wife Jane 55 b Selkirk, SEL; Children (all b Selkirk, SEL: Joseph 24 blacksmith; Robt 18 ag lab; Peter 15 mill worker; John 13 millworker; William 10 scholar; Grdson: James 7 scholar b Selkirk, SEL.¹²
     Robert Sinton immigrated in 1874 to NZ; via AUS, and is possibly the 21yr old from Berwick on the "Canterbury". Not listed in front index for the ship, but appears on list of single men, as 21 yr old male, carpenter from Berwick. Other Borders names on the same list of single men: John Lamb, 22, mason Peebles, Jas Leith, 18, ploughman from Berwick, Thos Ormiston, 22, ploughman from ROX, Peter Pringle, 19, shepherd from ROX, Wm Pollock, 21, ploughman from ROX, Samuel Russell, 19, from PEE, Andrew Swantson, 19, farm lab from Berwick (next to Robt S.), George Wilson, 24, farm lab ROX and Arch Wadell, 22, ploughman from ROX, Robert Young, 23, blacksmith from ROX.^13,14
     Here's a conundrum. Family anecdotal evidence, surviving letters etc, show that Robert was the son of Robert Sinton and Jane Park from Selkirk, and married Agnes Alexander in 1879 in NZ (neither marriage nor death certs being helpful in having his parent's names). However, a Scottish death certificate clearly shows that Robert, the son of Robert and Jane, died in Selkirk in 1874, the informant being father Robert. These two Roberts are therefore obviously not one and the same person, unless parents, Robert and Jane had two sons called Robert OR, father Robert gave the wrong name for the son who died. This latter is my current theory to explain this. The 1874 Robert was supposedly 18, but should have been 21, whereas his younger brother Peter would indeed have been 18 in 1874. In addition, I have found no documented evidence of Peter's existance beyond the 1871 census. he wasn't in the Scottish Lowlands in 1881, didn't marry in Scotland before 1905 and didn't die there before 1950, which all adds fuel to my speculative fire that father Robert just got the dead son's name wrong. Completely inconclusive, as he could have moved away from Scotland.^15,16